Dental Materials – Advantages & Disadvantages PORCELAIN FUSED TO METAL
GOLD ALLOY
This type of porcelain is a glasslike material that is “enameled” on top of metal shells. It is toothcolored and is used for crowns and fixed bridges
Gold alloy is a gold-colored mixture of gold, copper, and other metals and is used mainly for crowns and fixed bridges and some partial denture frameworks
Advantages
Advantages
❤ Good resistance to further decay if the restoration fits well ❤ Very durable, due to metal substructure ❤ The material does not cause tooth sensitivity ❤ Resists leakage because it can be shaped for a very accurate fit
❤ Good resistance to further decay if the restoration fits well ❤ Excellent durability; does not fracture under stress ❤ Does not corrode in the mouth ❤ Minimal amount of tooth needs to be removed ❤ Wears well; does not cause excessive wear to opposing teeth ❤ Resists leakage because it can be shaped for a very accurate fit
Disadvantages • More tooth must be removed (than for porcelain) for the metal substructure • Higher cost because it requires at least two office visits and laboratory services
The Facts About Fillings
Disadvantages • Is not tooth colored; alloy is yellow • Conducts heat and cold; may irritate sensitive teeth • High cost; requires at least two office visits and laboratory services
DENTAL BOARD OF CALIFORNIA 1432 Howe Avenue • Sacramento, California 95825
www.dbc.ca.gov Published by CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF CONSUMER AFFAIRS 5/04
The Facts About Fillings
DENTAL BOARD OF CALIFORNIA 1432 Howe Avenue • Sacramento, California 95825
www.dbc.ca.gov
Dental Materials Fact Sheet What About the Safety of Filling Materials? Patient health and the safety of dental treatments are the primary goals of California’s dental professionals and the Dental Board of California. The purpose of this fact sheet is to provide you with information concerning the risks and benefits of all the dental materials used in the restoration (filling) of teeth. The Dental Board of California is required by law* to make this dental materials fact sheet available to every licensed dentist in the state of California. Your dentist, in turn, must provide this fact sheet to every new patient and all patients of record only once before beginning any dental filling procedure. As the patient or parent/guardian, you are strongly encouraged to discuss with your dentist the facts presented concerning the filling materials being considered for your particular treatment. * Business and Professions Code 1648.10-1648.20
Allergic Reactions to Dental Materials Components in dental fillings may have side effects or cause allergic reactions, just like other materials we may come in contact with in our daily lives. The risks of such reactions are very low for all types of filling materials. Such reactions can be caused by specific components of the filling materials such as mercury, nickel, chromium, and/or beryllium alloys. Usually, an allergy will reveal itself as a skin rash and is easily reversed when the individual is not in contact with the material. There are no documented cases of allergic reactions to compos ite resin, glass ionomer, resin ionomer, or porcelain. However, there have been rare allergic responses reported with dental amalgam, porcelain fused to metal, gold alloys, and nickel or cobalt-chrome alloys.
PORCELAIN (CERAMIC)
NICKEL OR COBALT CHROME ALLOYS
Porcelain is a glass-like material formed into fillings or crowns using models of the prepared teeth. The material is toothcolored and is used in inlays, veneers, crowns and fixed bridges.
Nickel or cobalt-chrome alloys are mixtures of nickel and chromium. They are a dark silver metal color and are used for crowns and fixed bridges and most partial denture frameworks.
Advantages
❤ Good resistance to further decay if the restoration fits well ❤ Excellent durability; does not fracture under stress ❤ Does not corrode in the mouth ❤ Minimal amount of tooth needs to be removed ❤ Resists leakage because it can be shaped for a very accurate fit
❤ Very little tooth needs to be removed for use as a veneer; more tooth needs to be re moved for a crown because its strength is related to its bulk (size) ❤ Good resistance to further decay if the restoration fits well ❤ Is resistant to surface wear but can cause some wear on opposing teeth ❤ Resists leakage because it can be shaped for a very accurate fit ❤ The material does not cause tooth sensitivity
Disadvantages • Material is brittle and can break under biting forces • May not be recommended for molar teeth • Higher cost because it requires at least two office visits and laboratory services
Advantages
Disadvantages • Is not tooth colored; alloy is a dark silver metal color • Conducts heat and cold; may irritate sensitive teeth • Can be abrasive to opposing teeth • High cost; requires at least two office visits and laboratory services • Slightly higher wear to opposing teeth
If you suffer from allergies, discuss these potential problems with your dentist before a filling material is chosen. 2
The Facts About Fillings
7
Dental Materials – Advantages & Disadvantages GLASS IONOMER CEMENT
RESIN-IONOMER CEMENT
Glass ionomer cement is a selfhardening mixture of glass and organic acid. It is tooth-colored and varies in translucency. Glass ionomer is usually used for small fillings, cementing metal and porcelain/metal crowns, liners, and temporary restorations.
Resin ionomer cement is a mixture of glass and resin polymer and organic acid that hardens with exposure to a blue light used in the dental office. It is tooth colored but more translucent than glass ionomer cement. It is most often used for small fillings, cementing metal and porcelain metal crowns and liners.
Advantages ❤ Reasonably good esthetics ❤ May provide some help against decay because it releases fluoride ❤ Minimal amount of tooth needs to be removed and it bonds well to both the enamel and the dentin beneath the enamel ❤ Material has low incidence of producing tooth sensitivity ❤ Usually completed in one dental visit
Disadvantages • Cost is very similar to compos ite resin (which costs more than amalgam) • Limited use because it is not recommended for biting surfaces in permanent teeth • As it ages, this material may become rough and could increase the accumulation of plaque and chance of periodon tal disease • Does not wear well; tends to crack over time and can be dislodged
6
Advantages ❤ Very good esthetics ❤ May provide some help against decay because it releases fluoride ❤ Minimal amount of tooth needs to be removed and it bonds well to both the enamel and the dentin beneath the enamel ❤ Good for non-biting surfaces ❤ May be used for short-term primary teeth restorations
❤ May hold up better than glass
ionomer but not as well as
composite ❤ Good resistance to leakage ❤ Material has low incidence of producing tooth sensitivity ❤ Usually completed in one dental visit
Toxicity of Dental Materials Dental Amalgam Mercury in its elemental form is on the State of California’s Proposition 65 list of chemicals known to the state to cause reproductive toxicity. Mercury may harm the developing brain of a child or fetus. Dental amalgam is created by mixing elemental mercury (43 54%) and an alloy powder (46-57%) composed mainly of silver, tin, and copper. This has caused discussion about the risks of mercury in dental amalgam. Such mercury is emitted in minute amounts as vapor. Some concerns have been raised regarding possible toxicity. Scientific research continues on the safety of dental amalgam. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, there is scant evidence that the health of the vast majority of people with amalgam is compromised. The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and other public health organizations have investigated the safety of amalgam used in dental fillings. The conclusion: no valid scientific evi dence has shown that amalgams cause harm to patients with dental restorations, except in rare cases of allergy. The World Health Organization reached a similar conclusion stating, “Amal gam restorations are safe and cost effective.” A diversity of opinions exists regarding the safety of dental amalgams. Questions have been raised about its safety in preg nant women, children, and diabetics. However, scientific evi dence and research literature in peer-reviewed scientific journals suggest that otherwise healthy women, children, and diabetics are not at an increased risk from dental amalgams in their mouths. The FDA places no restrictions on the use of dental amalgam.
Disadvantages
Composite Resin
• Cost is very similar to compos ite resin (which costs more than amalgam) • Limited use because it is not recommended to restore the biting surfaces of adults • Wears faster than composite and amalgam
Some Composite Resins include Crystalline Silica, which is on the State of California’s Proposition 65 list of chemicals known to the state to cause cancer. It is always a good idea to discuss any dental treatment thoroughly with your dentist. 3
Dental Materials – Advantages & Disadvantages DENTAL AMALGAM FILLINGS
COMPOSITE RESIN FILLINGS
Dental amalgam is a self-hardening mixture of silver-tin-copper alloy powder and liquid mercury and is sometimes referred to as silver fillings because of its color. It is often used as a filling material and replacement for broken teeth.
Composite fillings are a mixture of powdered glass and plastic resin, sometimes referred to as white, plastic, or tooth-colored fillings. It is used for fillings, inlays, veneers, partial and complete crowns, or to repair portions of broken teeth.
Advantages
Disadvantages
Advantages
Disadvantages
❤ Durable; long lasting
• Refer to “What About the Safety of Filling Materials”
❤ Strong and durable
• Refer to “What About the Safety of Filling Materials”
❤ Wears well; holds up well to the forces of biting ❤ Relatively inexpensive ❤ Generally completed in one visit ❤ Self-sealing; minimal-to-no shrinkage and resists leakage ❤ Resistance to further decay is high, but can be difficult to find in early stages ❤ Frequency of repair and replacement is low
• Gray colored, not tooth colored • May darken as it corrodes; may stain teeth over time
❤ Tooth colored ❤ Single visit for fillings ❤ Resists breaking
• Requires removal of some healthy tooth
❤ Maximum amount of tooth preserved
• In larger amalgam fillings, the remaining tooth may weaken and fracture
❤ Small risk of leakage if bonded only to enamel
• Because metal can conduct hot and cold temperatures, there may be a temporary sensitivity to hot and cold. • Contact with other metals may cause occasional, minute electrical flow
❤ Does not corrode ❤ Generally holds up well to the forces of biting depending on product used ❤ Resistance to further decay is moderate and easy to find ❤ Frequency of repair or replace ment is low to moderate
T
he durability of any dental restoration is influenced not only by the material it is made from but also by the dentist’s technique when placing the restoration. Other factors include the supporting materials used in the procedure and the patient’s cooperation during the procedure. The length of time a restoration will last is dependent upon your dental hygiene, home care, and diet and chewing habits.
4
• Moderate occurrence of tooth sensitivity; sensitive to dentist’s method of applica tion • Costs more than dental amalgam • Material shrinks when hardened and could lead to further decay and/or tempera ture sensitivity • Requires more than one visit for inlays, veneers, and crowns • May wear faster than dental enamel • May leak over time when bonded beneath the layer of enamel
The Facts About Fillings
5
