JEK T
6 [1] : 55 - 61
ISSN : 2301 - 8968
!"#$%&%&' ()#$#' *)+"+,%&' -#.#' /".0&12%' 3#10' 3#1#' ' .%' 45&#' 60$%)078' 9%#":#28' 3#$%' !" #$%&'" ()*+" ,*%-$./0$12 !"3&%&"4.*5$6$7$ !"#"$%&'()*&*+,'-.+/%&0"&%&'1%)"23%$'()*&*+,'4&,5.#$,3%$'46%7%&%
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
Q;$-9O"$)*+A:*%-$./0$R7;$-9AC<;
55
JURNAL EKONOMI KUANTITATIF TERAPAN Vol. 6 No. 1 FEBRUARI 2013
>$%$" >&5-5)'$/$5" '&+&6$0/&.$$5" ;$+7$.$'$/" +&./$" %$>$/" ;&5%*'*5)" >.<).$;" >&;:$5)*5$5" %$&.$0A" 8&.'&;:$5)$5" -5%*+/.-" '&C-9" C*'*>" >&+$/" +&6$6$." %&5)$5" >&+$/57$" >&.'&;:$5)$5" -5%*+/.-" >$.-D-+$/$" 7$5)";&;:*'$">&9*$5)">$+$.":$-'">$+$."9<'$9";$*>*5" -5/&.5$+-$<5$9A 8$/&5" 3-$57$." 7$5)" C*'*>" ;&5$.-'" $%$9$0" D-+$/$" $9$;57$" 7$5)" C*'*>" -5%$0" %&5)$5" +&5%-.-57$" ;&5)*5%$5)" '&%$/$5)$5" >$.$" D-+$/$D$5@" +&0-5))$" %&5)$5" %&;-'-$5" %$>$/" ;&5%<.<5)" /*;:*057$" *+$0$" -5%*+/.-" '&.$6-5$5" $/$*>*5" *+$0$G*+$0$" 9$-557$A" #&:&.$%$$5" -5%*+/.-" '&C-9" %$5" '&.$6-5$5" %$9$;" >&.&'<5<;-$5" %-" %*'*5)" <9&0"+*$/*"'&57$/$$5":$0D$"+&:$)-$5":&+$."-5%*+/.-" '&C-9":&.9<'$+-"%-">&%&+$$5A"S9&0"'$.&5$"-/*@"$>$:-9$" %-"'$-/'$5"%&5)$5";$+$9$0"'&9&:-0$5"/&5$)$"'&.6$"%$5" +&;>-/57$"9*$+"9$0$5")$.$>$5@";$'$"$%$57$"-5%*+/.-" '&C-9" %-" >&%&+$$5" ;&.*>$'$5" +$9$0" +$/*" $9/&.5$/-=" >&;&C$0$557$@" 7$-/*" ;&;>&.9*$+" '&+&;>$/$5" :&.*+$0$"$/$*":&'&.6$A"!5%*+/.-"'&C-9"-5-";&;>*57$-" ;$+$"%&>$5"7$5)"C*'*>":$-'A"!5%*+/.-"'&C-9"%-"'$/$'$5" ;&;>*57$-" ;$+$" %&>$5" 7$5)" :$-'" +&0*:*5)$5" %&5)$5" +-=$/" '&*5))*9$557$" %$9$;" ;&57&.$>" /&5$)$" '&.6$A" 4&5$)$" '&.6$" ;&.*>$'$5" +*$/*" =$'/<." >.<%*'+-"+&0-5))$"%$9$;"'&)-$/$5"-5%*+/.-"%->&.9*'$5" +&6*;9$0"/&5$)$"'&.6$"7$5)";&;>*57$-"'&/&.$;>-9$5" %$5" '&;$;>*$5" /&./&5/*" +&+*$-" %&5)$5" '&:*/*0$5" >&.*+$0$$5" JK$%$/" '$.7$A" H-=$/" -5-9$0" 7$5)" %-;-9-'-" -5%*+/.-" '&C-9" *5/*'" >&.'&;:$5)$5" %-" ;$+$"7$5)"$'$5"%$/$5)A #$:*>$/&5" 3-$57$." ;&;-9-'-" '$D$+$5" >$.-D-+$/$" 7$5)" :&.>&%$;>-5)57$A" #$:*>$/&5" 3-$57$." 7$5)" /&.%-.-" %$.-" /*6*0" #&C$;$/$5" 6*)$" ;&.*>$'$5" +$9$0" +$/*" %$&.$0" /&;>$/" :&.'&;:$5)57$" -5%*+/.-" '&C-9A" #&C$;$/$5" 3-$57$." ;&;:&.-'$5" '<5/.-:*+-" 7$5)"+$5)$/":&.$./-"/&.0$%$>">&.'&;:$5)$5"&'<5<;-" '$:*>$/&5" )-$57$.A" H&;$'-5" /-5))-57$" $5)'$" >&./*;:*0$5" >&5%*%*'" ;&57&:$:'$5" +&;$'-5" /-5))-">*9$">&.;-5/$$5"9$>$5)$5"*+$0$"'$.&5$"+&'/<." -5%*+/.-" ;&57&.$>" C*'*>" :$57$'" /&5$)$" '&.6$A" B$9" -5-";&;:*'$"+&)$9$":-%$5)"*+$0$"7$5)";&57$5)'*/" >&.&'<5<;-$5"%-"+*$/*"%$&.$0A"8*9$*",$9-"7$5)"/&.'&5$9" %&5)$5" +&'/<." >$.-D-+$/$57$" +$5)$/" ;&5%*'*5)" /*;:*057$" :&.:$)$-" -5%*+/.-" '&C-9" %$5" '&.$6-5$5A" H&;$'-5":&.'&;:$5)57$"+&'/<.">$.-D-+$/$"%$5"+&'/<." -5%*+/.-" ;$'$" +&;$'-5" ;&5-5)'$/" >*9$" >&5%$>$/$5" ;$+7$.$'$/57$A"I&5-5)'$/57$">&5%$>$/$5";$+7$.$'$/" ;&5)$'-:$/'$5";&5-5)'$/57$"'&:*/*0$5";$+7$.$'$/" /&.0$%$>" +$.$5$" >.$+$.$5$" +&>&./-" :$5)*5$5" >&.*;$0$5@">&./<'<$5@">&.'$5/<.$5@"+$5))$0"$/$*>*5" >*.$" 7$5)" ;&5))*5$'$5" :$0$5" :$/*" :$/$" %$9$;"
56
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
()*%"+&,-.)/012 A' E F B B B B LL
()*%"+&!$-"4"&:$15" 'A' FG B' H E E F BEA
M)*#$1N&K"0"&6"/$&8:C&K$/"&!)%2D);&!"+)-&BO'B
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
!"#$%&%&'()#$#'*)+"+,%&'-#.#'/".0&12%'3#10'3#1#'.%'45&#'60$%)078'9%#":#28'3#$%''''!"#$%&'(#)*+,#-+&.%/01%2#"#3'&'#4/+5%6%7%8
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
"
,&.%$+$.'$5" >&.0-/*5)$5" /&.+&:*/" ;$'$" 6*;9$0" +$;>&9"7$5)"%-$;:-9"$%$9$0"+&:$57$'"NM">&5)*+$0$" :$/*":$/$A !"#$%&%&'F%"%52';5A25&%'352A#".# K&).&+-" 9-5-&." :&.)$5%$" %$9$;" >&5&9-/-$5" -5-" %-)*5$'$5"*5/*'";&9-0$/":$)$-;$5$"0*:*5)$5"$5/$.$" /&5$)$" '&.6$" %$5" ;<%$9" /&.0$%$>" >.<%*'+-" -5%*+/.-" >&5).$6-5" :$/*" :$/$" %-" ?&+$" 4*9-'*>" #&C$;$/$5" 3-$57$."#$:*>$/&5"3-$57$."7$5)"%-.*;*+'$5"+&:$)$-" :&.-'*/A ^5_'?(@(A(BP^5`P(A(BL^5`L"a"*"
"JP2
EI%'J'KEI%'(%A"%>%)#"&%'<+5>%&%5"';5A25&%'(5?#2#' (525,7#)L \6-" b" -5-" %->&.)*5$'$5" *5/*'" >&5)*6-$5" F$.-$:&9G"
F$.-$:&9".&).&+-"+&C$.$"+&.&;>$'"$/$*";&5)*6-"/&5$)$" '&.6$" J`P2" %$5" ;<%$9" J" `L2" +&C$.$" :&.+$;$G+$;$" /&.0$%$>" >.<%*'+-" -5%*+/.-" >&5)&.$6-5" :$/*" :$/$" %-" ?&+$"4*9-'*>"#&C$;$/$5"3-$57$."#$:*>$/&5"3-$57$." J_2A"I&5*.*/"3*6$.$/-"JLMMW2@"5-9$-"b"%$>$/"%-">&.<9&0" %&5)$5";&5))*5$'$5"=<.;*9$+-"+&:$)$-":&.-'*/"O b"0-/*5)"["
R 2 /k #1 """ (1# R 2 ) /(n # k)
"
JL2
#&/&.$5)$5"O b"" ["X-9$-"b"0$+-9">&.0-/*5)$5 KL(( ?(C"#$%&#'(.#+#)/&',%&(1#)*,'., #"" "[",$57$'57$"F$.-$:&9"%$9$;";<%&9".&).&+5"" ["\'*.$5"+$;>&9
EI%'1'KEI%'(%A"%>%)#"&%'<+5>%&%5"';5A25&%'(5?#2#' -#2&%#$'L \6-"/"%-")*5$'$5"*5/*'";&5)&/$0*-"$>$'$0"F$.-$:&9" /&5$)$"'&.6$"J`P2"%$5";<%$9"J`L2":&.>&5)$.*0"+&C$.$" >$.+-$9"/&.0$%$>"F$.-$:&9">.<%*'+-"-5%*+/.-">&5).$6-5" :$/*" :$/$" %-" ?&+$" 4*9-'*>" #&C$;$/$5" 3-$57$." #$:*>$/&5" 3-$57$." J_2" %&5)$5" $+*;+-" F$.-$:&9" 9$-5" '<5+/$5A" 8$%$" >&5)*6-$5" 0->$%$" /-5)'$/" %&.$6$/" '&7$'-5$5" /&./&5/*A" I&5*.*/" X$/$" c-.$D$5" JLMMLOTMd2"5-9$-"/G0-/*5)"%->&.<9&0"%&5)$5"=<.;*9$+-" +&:$)$-":&.-'*/O /-"?
bi # bi "" " S(bi)
"
"
"
JT2
#&/&.$5)$5"O /-" [" ,&+$.57$"5-9$-"/G0-/*5) :-( ?( C"#$%&#'( )#*)#%&( 7,)%&,0( 8,'*( !#D&( .,)&( %,/7#0( 8,'*( %->
G5"5"10)#"' ()#$#' *)+"+,%&' !"#$%$&'#( $)( *#+,"-(.#"'G5"5"10)#"'(%>#1'-2+.0)&% \5/*'" ;&5&5/*'$5" +'$9$" &'<5<;-" -5%*+/.-" :$/*" :$/$@" /&'5-'" $5$9-+-+" 7$5)" %-)*5$'$5" %&5)$5" ;<%&9" 0*:*5)$5" $5/$.$" >.<%*'+-" %&5)$5" /&5$)$" '&.6$" %$5" ;<%$9A"?&5)$5"=<.;*9$+-57$O G(?(@4HIBI( A"`L(BJ( A&*" "
"
Jd2
8&.+$;$$5"d"7$5)"'&;*%-$5"%-57$/$'$5"'&"%$9$;" :&5/*'"9<)$.-/;$";&56$%-":&.-'*/ K'G(?(0'(@(A(BPA" ^5`P" A(B"LA" ^5`La*""JN2 #&/&.$5)$5O _["8.<%*'+-",$/*",$/$"J\5-/2 `P["4&5$)$"#&.6$"JZ$;2 `L["I<%$9"JK>2 ,&.%$+$.'$5"8&.+$;$$5"N"%$>$/"%-/&5/*'$5"+'$9$"
57
JURNAL EKONOMI KUANTITATIF TERAPAN Vol. 6 No. 1 FEBRUARI 2013
&'<5<;-+" %$9$;" >.<+&+" >.<%*'+-" -5%*+/.-" :$/*" :$/$" +&:$)$-":&.-'*/A" IE4(L&!,(BPA(BL"e"P@";$'$"-5%*+/.-">&5).$6-5":$/*":$/$" %-" ?&+$" 4*9-'*>" #&C$;$/$5" 3-$57$." #$:*>$/&5" 3-$57$.@":&.$%$"%$9$;"'<5%-+-",&8#.%$,&0'@.3"#&' *<'A8%2.B JE4(L&!,(BPA(BL"["P@";$'$"-5%*+/.-">&5).$6-5":$/*":$/$" %-" ?&+$" 4*9-'*>" #&C$;$/$5" 3-$57$.@" #$:*>$/&5" 3-$57$.":&.$%$"%$9$;"'<5%-+-"8*&$3%&3'#.3"#&'3*' $8%2.B ME4(L&!,(BPA(BL"f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
d">&55)*+$0$"$/$*"W">&.+&5@"+&9$56*/57$"%--'*/-"<9&0" '&9<;><'" *;*." LVGTP" 7$-/*" +&:$57$'" PM" >&5)*+$0$" $/$*"LM">&.+&5@"'&9<;><'"*;*."LMGLN"7$-/*"+&:$57$'" W" >&5)*+$0$" $/$*" PV" >&.+&5@" '&9<;><'" *;*." TWGdT" 7$-/*"g">&5)*+$0$"$/$*"Pd">&.+&5@"'&9<;><'"*;*."ddG dU" 7$-/*" N" >&5)*+$0$" $/$*" PM" >&.+&5" %$5" '&9<;><'" *;*."NMGNN"7$-/*"d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
:$%?*;?D&8*)1& 7!"+)-9 BOQBI BEQG' GBQGH GAQFG FFQFL IOQII IEQEO ()*%"+
()*%"+&J$/;?-.$7?1"-49 A 'O 'G H I F G IO
3$1/$-0"/$ 7P9 'E BO BE 'F 'O A E 'OO
M)*#$1N&K"0"&J$/;?-.$-RBO'B&
8$%$" 4$:&9" L" %$>$/" %-9-0$/" :$0D$" %$.-" NM" 6*;9$0" .&+><5%&5" 7$5)" %-/&9-/-@" 6*;9$0" .&+><5%&5" *5/*'" '&9<;><'" *;*." TLGTg" 6*;9$057$" >$9-5)" :$57$'" 7$-/*"PT">&5)*+$0$"$/$*"LV">&.+&5"+&%$5)'$5"*5/*'" '&9<;><'"*;*."NVGVM"6*;9$057$">$9-5)"+&%-'-/"0$57$"
58
&
!2-4D"0&3$-.2.2D"MK MC3 MC8&"0")&="-4&/$.$1"5"0 K2;%?*"&,R,,R,,, M"15"-" &:?0"&K$-;"/"1
()*%"+&J$/;?-.$7?1"-49 'O 'A 'E F B IO
3$1/$-0"/$ 7P9 BO GE GB A F 'OO
M)*#$1T&K"0"&J$/;?-.$-&RBO'B
4$:&9"T";&5*56*'$5":$0D$">&5%-%-'$5">&5)*+$0$" 9&:-0" :$57$'" 9*9*+$5" HI8" :&.6*;9$0" PW" >&5)*+$0$@" HI\" :&.6*;9$0" PV" >&5)*+$0$@" H?" :&.6*;9$0" PM" >&5)*+$0$@"7$5)";&;-9-'-"/-5)'$/">&5%-%-'$5"?->9<;$" 0$57$"d"<.$5)"%$5"7$5)";&;-9-'-"/-5)'$/">&5%-%-'$5" +$.6$5$"0$57$"L"<.$5)A"K&5%$057$"/-5)'$/">&5%-%-'$5" ;&56$%-"'&5%$9$"'$.&5$"/-5)'$/">&5%-%-'$5":&.>&.$5" 7#'+&'*(1,*&(7#'*3%,2,(.,0,/(#$%&#'%&(7)".3!%&(.,'( ;&5-5)'$/'$5"%$7$"+$-5)"%&5)$5">&.*+$0$$5"9$-5A !"#$"%&'()*+$*",-./$# !5F&+/$+-h;<%$9" %$.-" NM" >&5)*+$0$" -5%*+/.-" >&5).$6-5" :$/*" :$/$" %-" ?&+$" 4*9-'*>" #&C$;$/$5" 3-$57$." #$:*>$/&5" 3-$57$.@" :&.'-+$." $5/$.$" K>" dPAUMMAMMM"+$;>$-"%&5)$5"K>APLNAWMMAMMM"A"!5F&+/$+-" -5%*+/.-">&5).$6-5":$/*":$/$"%-"?&+$"4*9-'*>"+&:$)-$5" :&+$." :&.$+$9" %$.-" ;<%$9" +&5%-.-" %$5" $%$" +&:$)-$5" '&C-9" >&5)*+$0$" ;&5&.-;$" ;<%$9" >-56$;$5" *5/*'" >&5)&;:$5)$5" *+$0$57$" 7$5)" %->&.<9&0" %$.-" ^8?" %$5"'<>&.$+-"7$5)"$%$"%-"?&+$"4*9-'*>A 012#$3%4)'$5$%6)78$,%0$2%6)78$ Z*;9$0"/&5$)$"'&.6$">&5)*+$0$"-5%*+/.-":$/*":$/$" %-" ?&+$" 4*9-'*>" :&.'-+$." $5/$.$" d" +$;>$-" g" <.$5)" *5/*'"+&/-$>">&5)*+$0$A"?$.-"NM"*5-/"*+$0$"-5%*+/.-"
!"#$%&%&'()#$#'*)+"+,%&'-#.#'/".0&12%'3#10'3#1#'.%'45&#'60$%)078'9%#":#28'3#$%''''!"#$%&'(#)*+,#-+&.%/01%2#"#3'&'#4/+5%6%7%8
>&5).$6-5" :$/*" :$/$" %-" ?&+$" 4*9-'*>" #&C$;$/$5" 3-$57$." #$:*>$/&5" 3-$57$." %$>$/" ;&57&.$>" /&5$)$" '&.6$"+&:$57$'"LVW"<.$5)"7$5)"+&:$)-$5":&+$.":&.$+$9" %$.-" ?&+$" 4*9-'*>" #&C$;$/$5" 3-$57$." #$:*>$/&5" 3-$57$." +&5%-.-" %$5" $%$" :&:&.$>$" 7$5)" :&.$+$9" %$.-" 9*$." ?&+$" 4*9-'*>" #&C$;$/$5" 3-$57$." #$:*>$/&5" 3-$57$.A Z*;9$0" 6$;" '&.6$" /&5$)$" '&.6$" -5%*+/.-" >&5).$6-5" :$/*" :$/$" %-" ?&+$" 4*9-'*>" #&C$;$/$5" 3-$57$." #$:*>$/&5"3-$57$."$%$9$0":&.'-+$."$5/$.$"V"+$;>$-" g"6$;">&.0$.-A\5/*'"6$;"'&.6$"+&9$;$"+&/$0*5"%&5)$5" V"'$9-">.<+&+">.<%*'+-"%$>$/";&5C$>$-"$5$/$.$"gAULM" +$;>$-"PWAdWM"6$;">&./$0*5A" M0,$#='-2+.0)&%'/".0&12%'-5"A2#I%"'3#10'3#1#' Z*;9$0" >.<%*'+-" 7$5)" %-0$+-9'$5" <9&0" +&/-$>" >&5).$6-5" :$/*" :$/$" %-" ?&+$" 4*9-'*>" :&.:&%$G" :&%$" /&.)$5/*5)" %&5)$5" 6*;9$0" 6$;" '&.6$" %$5" 6*;9$0" -5F&+/$+-h;<%$9" 7$5)" %-)*5$'$5A" 8.<%*'+-" /&./-5))-" $%$9$0" +&:&+$." WNAMMM" *5-/h/$0*5" %$5" >.<%*'+-" /&.&5%$0"$%$9$0"+&:&+$."LMANMM"*5-/h/$0*5A ;5A25&%'F%"5#2'352A#".# H&/&9$0" %-9$'*'$5" .&).&+-" ;<%&9" C*//DE*"02%$" 7$5)" %-&+/-;$+-" %&5)$5" ;<%&9"6*"/2.' 2*0" /&.0$%$>" >.<%*'+-" J^5_2" %&5)$5" F$.-$:&9" :&:$+" /&5$)$" '&.6$" J^5`P2" %$5" ;<%$9" J^5`L2" %&5)$5" ;&5))*5$'$5" 8.<).$;"H8HH"PN@";$'$"%->&.<9&0"0$+-9"+&>&./-"/&.9-0$/" >$%$"4$:&9"dA"
%-9$'*'$5" *6-" 5<.;$9-/$+" %&5)$5" ;&5))*5$'$5" >.<).$;" H8HH" PN@" ;$'$" %->&.<9&0" 0$+-9" +&:$)$-" :&.-'*/A !"#$%&I& U"/2%&852&>?1*"%20"/ 8-/0"-.."1.2[$.&J$/2.)"% IO OROOO ORIIH ORL'E
> C$"-& :?%*?4?1?ZQM*21-?Z&\ ]/=*;@&M24@&7BQ0"2%$.9 M)*#$1&N&K"0"&312*$1&K2?%"+
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b2A" H&/&9$0" %-9$'*'$5" *6-" ;*9/-'<9-5-&.-/$+" /&.0$%$>" E$.-$:&9"8.<%*'+-"J^5_2@"/&5$)$"'&.6$"J^5`P2@";<%$9" J^5`L2"%&5)$5";&5))*5$'$5"8.<).$;"H8HH"PN@";$'$" %->&.<9&0"0$+-9"+&:$)$-":&.-'*/A
!"#$%&F&U"/2%&J$41$/2&!$1+".";&V-31?.)D/2 W"12"#$% :?-/0"-0" !$-"4"&:$15"&7V-!$-"4"&:$15"9 C?."%&7V-C?."%9 JQMY)"1$ CD18%E1E6 ()*%"+&S#/$1Z"/2
2%;"4&F&G%1/4&<$/&H34E5A4/)/"#/8%1
!A"B1/") QO@FGG 7O@GAI9 O@ABG 7O@'GI9XXX O@I'I 7O@''O9XXX ORHIH HGROEHXXX FL
M)*#$1&N&K"0"&312*$1&K2?%"+
?$.-"4$:&9"d"%$>$/"%-.*;*+'$5">&.+$;$$5".&).&+-" %$.-";<%&9"+&+*$-"%&5)$5">&.+$;$$5"P"7$-/*"O ^5_"["GM@dTT"a"M@WLT"^5`P"a"M@NPN"^5"`L"" JW2 P2A"\6-"X<.;$9-/$+ \6-" X<.;$9-/$+" :&./*6*$5" *5/*'" ;&5)*6-" $>$'$0" .&+-%*$9"%$.-";<%&9".&).&+-"7$5)"%-:*$/":&.%-+/.-:*+-" 5<.;$9" $/$*" /-%$'A" I<%&9" .&).&+-" 7$5)" :$-'" $%$9$0" ;&;-9-'-" %-+/.-:*+-" .&+-%*$9" 7$5)" 5<.;$9" $/$*" ;&5%&'$/-" 5<.;$9A" H$9$0" +$/*" C$.$" 7$5)" %-)*5$'$5" $%$9$0" %&5)$5" *6-" 9*2+*0*#*5DA+,#&*5A" H&/&9$0"
C?.$% V-7!$-"4"&:$15"9 V-7C?."%9
2A4"#%)6" OREGE OREGE
>2%"2&W,^ 'RIHF 'RIHF
M)*#$1&N&K"0"&312*$1&K2?%"+ K$;$-.$-0&W"12"#%$N&31?.)D/2&7V-31?.)D/29
,&.%$+$.'$5"0$+-9">&5)*6-$5"7$5)"%-"/*56*'$5">$%$" 4$:&9"N";&5*56*'$5":$0D$";$+-5)G;$+-5)"F$.-$:9&" 7$5)"%-/&9-/-";&;-9-'-"5-9$-"F*2.#%&8."9&:-0":&+$."%$.-" M@P"%$5"E!b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
59
JURNAL EKONOMI KUANTITATIF TERAPAN Vol. 6 No. 1 FEBRUARI 2013
J^5_2@"/&5$)$"'&.6$"J^5`P2@"%$5";<%$9"J^5`L2@%&5)$5" ;&5))*5$'$5"8.<).$;"H8HH"PN@";$'$"%->&.<9&0"0$+-9" +&:$)$-":&.-'*/A 2%;"4&I& G%1/4&<$/&G"8"#A15".%1E1/8%1& >?@ '@ B@ G@
W"12"#
%$!A"B1/")
:?-/0"-0" !$-"4"&:$15"&7V-&_'9 C?."%&7V-&_B9
ORIOH OROEF QOR'B'
0
M24@ BRBBH ORHLG Q'RAFB
OROG' ORFGB OROHB
M)*#$1&N&K"0"&312*$1&K2?%"+ K$;$-.$-0&W"12"#%$N&]#?%)0$&J$/2.)"%
,&.%$+$.'$5" 4$:&9" g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`P2" %$5" ;<%$9" J^5`L2" %->&.<9&0" 5-9$-" b" 0-/*5)" [gT@MVg" e" b" /$:&9[" T@LN" %&5)$5" /-5)'$/" +-)5-=-'$5+-" JH-)A2" M@MMM" f" M@MN" -5-" :&.$./-" :$0D$" /&5$)$" '&.6$" J^5`P2" %$5" ;<%$9" J^5`L2" +&C$.$" +&.&;>$'" :&.>&5)$.*0" %&*'&$!,'( +#)2,.,7( 7)".3!%&( FK'GE( 7#'*),-&'( 1,+3( :$/$"%-"?&+$"4*9-'*>"#&C$;$/$5"3-$57$."#$:*>$/&5" 3-$57$.A" B$+-9" $5$9-+-+" .&).&+-" ;&5*56*'$5" 5-9$-" KL[" M@gNg" $./-57$" :$0D$" gN@g" >&.+&5" %$.-" F$.-$+-" 6*;9$0">.<%*'+-"-5%*+/.-">&5).$6-5":$/*":$/$"%-"?&+$" 4*9-'*>"#&C$;$/$5"3-$57$."#$:*>$/&5"3-$57$."%$>$/" %-6&9$+'$5"<9&0"'&%*$"F$.-$:&9":&:$+"7$-/*"/&5$)$"'&.6$" J^5`P2"%$5"I<%$9"J^5`L2"+&%$5)'$5"+-+$57$"+&:&+$." M@LdT" $/$*" Ld@T" >&.+&5" %-6&9$+'$5" <9&0" F$.-$:&9" 9$-5" 7$5)"/-%$'"%-;$+*'$5"'&"%$9$;";<%&9 EI%'1'K'EI%'(%A"%>%)#"&%'<+5>%&%5"';5A25&%'(5?#2#' -#2&%#$'L ,&.%$+$.'$5"4$:&9"d"%$>$/"%-9-0$/":$0D$"0$+-9"*6-" >$.+-$9" %&5)$5" ;&5))*5$'$5" ;<%&9"C*//DE*"02%$" 7$5)" %-" &+/-;$+-" %&5)$5" ;<%&9" %<*:9&" 9<)" /&.0$%$>" F$.-$:&9":&:$+"/&5$)$"'&.6$"J^5`P2"%$5";<%$9"J^5`L2" 7$5)"%$>$/"%-*6-'$5"+&:$)$-":&.-'*/"O S9&0"'$.&5$"5-9$-"/0-/*5)"/&5$)$"'&.6$"J^5`P2"["V@MWT" e"/"/$:&9"[P@VWd"%$5"5-9$-"/"0-/*5)";<%$9"J^5`L2"["d@VVN" e" /" /$:&9" P@VWd" ;$'$" BM" %-/<9$'" %$5" BP" %-/&.-;$A" !5-" 1#),)+&( ,.,( 7#'*,)32( %&*'&$!,'( .,'( 7"%&+&6( %#:,),( >$.+-$9"$5/$.$"/&5$)$"'&.6$J^5`P2"%$5";<%$9"J^5`L2
60
()#$#'*)+"+,%&'-5"A2#I%"'3#10'3#1#'.%'45&#' 60$%)07' <5?#,#1#"' 9%#":#2' <#N07#15"' 9%#":#2 ,&.%$+$.'$5" >&.+$;$$5" W@" ;$'$" %$>$/" %-0-/*5)" +'$9$"&'<5<;-+"-5%*+/.-">&5).$6-5":$/*":$/$@"%&5)$5" /#'-3/0,2!,'(!"#$%&#'()#*)#%&(+#',*,(!#)-,(FK'HIE( .,'( <".,0( FK'HJE( 8,&+3( BP( A( BL" [" M@WLT" a" M@NPN" [" I;MMY;( 1#),)+&( BP( A( BL" e" P" 6$%-" +&C$.$" +-;*9/$5" +'$9$" &'<5<;-+"J&C<5<;-C"<="+C$9&2"%$.-"!5%*+/.-"8&5).$6-5" ,$/*" ,$/$" %-" ?&+$" 4*9-'*>" #&C$;$/$5" 3-$57$." #$:*>$/&5"3-$57$."$%$9$0"H&8#.%$,&0'@.3"#&'3*'A8%2.' '$.&5$" 0$+-9" >&56*;9$0$557$" 9&:-0" :&+$." %$.-" +$/*A" (./-57$" 6-'$" +&;*$" -5>*/" 7$-/*" /&5$)$" '&.6$" J^5`P2" %$5";<%$9"J^5`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
!"#$%&%&'()#$#'*)+"+,%&'-#.#'/".0&12%'3#10'3#1#'.%'45&#'60$%)078'9%#":#28'3#$%''''!"#$%&'(#)*+,#-+&.%/01%2#"#3'&'#4/+5%6%7%8
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b$'*9/$+"Q'<5<;-"\5-F&.+-/$+"!5%<5&+-$A (%-5-5)+-0@"H.-@"%$5"#$%$.*+;$5A"LMMWA"F.*#,'()*&*+,'L,)#*A" Q%-+-"#&%*$A_<)7$'$./$"O",8bQ"i"_<)7$'$./$A (0;$5@" Q&5)A" LMMdA"()*&*+,4( Z,'.3'*( W( T),$'."( <#.&,( 8.$/$;$A (.-<'$@"!A3AXA"LMPMA"H'$9$"Q'<5<;-+"!5%*+/.-"#&.$6-5$5"4&5*5" !'$/"%-"#&C$;$/$5"?$D$5@"#$:*>$/&5"#9*5)'*5)@"A)#,=D $,"8.<).$;"HP".&)*9&.@"Z*.*+$5"Q'<5<;-"8&;:$5)*5$5" b$'*9/$+"Q'<5<;-"\5-F&.+-/$+"\%$7$5$@"?&5>$+$.A ,$%$5"8*+$/"H/$/-+/-'@"LMMLA"j!%>%'F.&0%N'E%2%+'K&0)%kA" ,$%$5"8*+$/"H/$/-+/-'"8.$+$.A ,$%$5"8*+$/"H/$/-+/-'"8.$+$.A ?6<6<0$%-'*+*;<@"H*;-/.">.<%*'+-" 397C&.-5&"8$%$"84A"b9<.$"H$D-/$"Y0&;-5%<"I&%$5A"F.$,$" 8.<).$;"H/*%-"!9;*"I$5$6&;&5@"8.<).$;"8$+C$"H$.6$5$" \5-F&.+-/$+"H*;$/&.$"\/$.$A"H*;$/&.$"\/$.$A
b&:.-" 3*+D$5%-A" LMMgA" b$'/<.G=$'/<." _$5)" I&;>&5)$.*0-" !;>9&;&5/$+-"#&:-6$'$5"8&5)&;:$5)$5"!5%*+/.-",<.G %-.$5"?-"H*;$/&.$",$.$/A",*9&/-5",!8?"E<9A"`E"X<5&)<.-.-+"4&.0$%$>"8&.*+$0$$5"I$5*=$'/*."_$5)" 4&.%$=/$."?-",*.+$"Q=&'"Z$'$./$A"Z*.5$9"Q'<5<;-"8&;G :$5)*5$5A"E<9*;&"`"X&.$+-@"?$5"\+$0$"I$'.<" #&C-9@"%$5"I&5&5)$0 " J#\#I2AZ$'$./$A ^-5C<9-5@"(.+7$%A"PUUUA"()*&*+,'-.+/%&0"&%&A"H4!Q"_#8XA" _<)7$'$./$ <,2,8,',;(R*3%(^'.),4(JVV`4(5!,0,([!"'"/&%(.,'([$%&#'%&( 8&5))*5$$5"b$'/<."i"=$'/<."8.<%*'+-"%$9$;"\+$0$/$5-" 8$%-" H$D$0" %-" ?&+$" H*%$6-@" #&C$;$/$5" H$D$5@" #$:*G >$/&5" ,*9&9&5)@" A)#,=$," 8.<).$;" HP" .&)*9&.@" Z*.*+$5" Q'<5<;-"8&;:$5)*5$5"b$'*9/$+"Q'<5<;-"\5-F&.+-/$+" \%$7$5$@"?&5>$+$.A X$/$" c-.$D$5A" LMMLA" C%#%' L"6%N' L.+%N%+,' $3%3,$3,)' PT$3%3,$3,),',&<#.&$,%U'4&3")'()*&*+,'E%&'O,$&,$'B?&5G >$+$."#&.$.$+"Q;$+ X-$" (.-+$5/-5-" H*%-:-$@" ^*0" 8*/*A" LMMWA" (5$9-+-+"(8*&*+,8' M<'$8%2.(a,'([$%&#'%&(N)".3!%&(^'.3%+)&(T#'+#'*(>,',2( ^-$/" ?-" #&C$;$/$5" #&%-.-@" #$:*>$/&5" 4$:$5$5@"F.$,$" 8.<).$;" 8$+C$" +$.6$5$@" 8.<).$;" I$)-+/&." &'<5<;-" 8&;:$5)*5$5"\5-F&.+-/$+"\%$7$5$@"?&5>$+$.A 8*.5$D$/-@"X-"#&/*/@"%''A"LMMdA"O")"'KJ%#'L%&%J.+.&'M=.#D %$,B'?&5>$+$."O"b$'*9/$+"Q'<5<;-"\5-F&.+-/$+"\%$7$5$A K-/<5)$@"(:%*..$0;$5"%''ALMMPA"9.=.&6"6")%&'6%&'V,&0D )"&0%&' W,6"=;" Z$'$./$O^&;:$)$" 8&5&.:-/" b$'*9/$+" Q'<5<;-"\5-F&.+-/$+"!5%<5&+-$ K" 4&5$)$" #&.6$"!5%*+/.-"K*;$0"4$5))$",$/*",$/$"%-"?&+$",$.$5" #&C$;$/$5" (;:$.$D$" #$:*>$/&5" H&;$.$5)A" H'.->+-A" b$'*9/$+"!9;*"H<+-$9"\5-F&.+-/$+"H&;$.$5)@"0"O"UVA H-;$56*5/$'@" 8$7$;$5A" PUUMA"-.&0%&3%#' ()*&*+,' A"+/.#' E%7%'L%&"$,%A"Z$'$./$O"b$'*9/$+"Q'<5<;-"\5-F&.+-/$+" !5%<5&+-$ H*)-7<5$" !++*"8&5/-5)A"Z$'$./$"30$9-$"!5%<5&+-$ 4.-D$07*5-" H*$.+$5$@" X-" X7<;$5A" LMMUA" H'$9$" Q'<5<;-+" !5%*+/.-" K*;$0" 4$5))$" #&.$6-5$5" ,$;:*" %-" ?&+$" #0$7*:-0-"#&C$;$/$5",$5)9-"#$:*>$/&5",$5)9-@"A)#,=$," 8.<).$;" HP" .&)*9&.@" Z*.*+$5" Q'<5<;-" 8&;:$5)*5$5" b$'*9/$+"Q'<5<;-"\5-F&.+-/$+"\%$7$5$@"?&5>$+$.A c-D-/" H&/-$/-A" LMMVA" (5$9-+-+" 8&5)$.*0" b$'/<." 8.<%*'+-" 4&.0$%$>"8.<%*'+-"!5%*+/.-"8&5)$+$>$5"!'$5"?-"#<5&)<.
61
